SP Dismisses Allegations of Bias Against African Sovereign Ratings at G-20 Summit
S&P Global Ratings has firmly rejected recent accusations that it unfairly penalizes African countries in its sovereign credit assessments, emphasizing that it applies the same long-established methodology to all nations. Roberto Sifon-Arevalo, S&P’s global head of sovereign ratings, told reporters at an event on the sidelines of the G-20 summit in Johannesburg that the agency’s criteria and processes have been publicly available for decades.
He noted that some critics wrongly benchmark African economies against structurally different markets such as Europe or the US, instead of comparing them with regions like Latin America or Southeast Asia, which share more economic similarities. 
Sifon-Arevalo admitted there is a human element in their ratings, but defended their judgments, saying: “We’re people … we are entitled to opinions … our opinion might not be the same as others. We try to do our best.” 
His remarks come amid growing pressure from African policy experts and financial leaders. A panel of experts under South Africa’s G-20 presidency recently called for stronger oversight of global rating agencies, accusing them of “perception biases” that inflate borrowing costs for African nations. 
Meanwhile, prominent voices like Sim Tshabalala, CEO of Africa’s largest bank, have condemned the lack of transparency in how rating models are built, arguing that African governments may be rated four notches lower than their fundamentals warrant. 


